Vassar Institute Signature Program Offers a Fresh Look at What It Means to ‘Go to the Source’
The Vassar mantra, “Go to the source,” is credited to early faculty member Lucy Maynard Salmon, who is said to have coined it shortly after she came to the College in 1887 to establish the History Department. On November 9, two members of the faculty and two administrators hosted a day-long symposium designed to examine the benefits – and the limitations – of going to the source.
The event, titled “Going to the Source: Opportunities to Co-create Institutional and Individual Character,” was held at the Vassar Institute for the Liberal Arts, adjacent to the campus. Co-conveners of the program were: Wendy Maragh Taylor, Associate Dean of the College for Student Growth and Engagement; Payton Small, Assistant Professor of Psychological Science; Leora Gansworth, Assistant Professor of American and Native American Studies; and Christina Johnson, Assistant Dean for Grants Development and Administration.
In his keynote address, Ojibwe scholar Dr. Anton Treuer noted that some sources of information about Native Americans are better than others. “Most of the books written about Native people were written by non-natives who never talked to one,” said Treuer, who is a Professor of Ojibwe Language at Bemidji (MN) State University. “That’s not native history; that’s White man’s Indian.”
EMBED VIDEO HERE-(NEED LINK OR CODE FROM CRAIG)
COPY
Treuer compared the loss of reliable sources of information to the game of Jenga. “When you stack blocks on top of each other and pull out enough blocks, it destabilizes the whole tower,” he said. “What a lot of people aren’t aware of is we are also playing Jenga with human bodies of knowledge and ways of knowing.”
Throughout his 90-minute talk, Treuer spoke about the progress Ojibwes and other Native Americans have made in expanding and promoting knowledge of their language and culture, thereby providing more reliable sources of information. He also said he was pleased to see steps taken to acknowledge the indignities and atrocities visited upon Native Americans throughout history.
Treuer noted that President Joe Biden had issued a public apology to Native Americans for the establishment of boarding schools for young Native Americans that promoted White culture. “It’s baby steps, but keep them coming,” he said. “It’s just a first step, and we need other steps.”
Treuer said he was optimistic that source material about Native Americans and other aspects of American history and culture would continue to improve. He alluded to a famous quote from Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., who said: “The arc of history is long, but it bends toward justice.”
“There is truth to this,” Treuer said, “but there are troughs, and troughs are damaging."
In a discussion that followed Treuer’s talk, panelists continued to reflect on the challenge of finding sources that could lead them to valid conclusions. One panelist, Assistant Professor of History Ashanti Shih, said she once conducted research at the New York Botanical Gardens about a noted botanist.
She later discovered that the botanist had had a key collaborator, a native Hawaiian whose name had been omitted from the material she had obtained. She said she obtained the collaborator’s name from herbarium specimen records, which showed he was involved in the collecting process.
Another panelist, James G. Cantres ’08, Associate Professor of Africana, Puerto Rican, and Latino Studies at Hunter College, recalled a conversation he had had with a fellow graduate student several years ago. Cantres said the student had told him he was conducting research on French colonialism in Africa and had obtained all his information from an institute in Aix-en-Provence, France, that housed documents on the subject. “He was writing about people in Africa, but he wasn’t interested in going to Africa,” Cantres said.
The co-conveners of the program said they believed the event had shed significant light on the information gaps that sometimes arise when researchers “go to the source.”
“It was an honor to hear from each of our esteemed guests and consider what source means to each of us,” Gansworth said. “Dr. Treuer’s opening talk brought a deeply embodied practice of storytelling through Ojibwe lifeways— a source of kinship, continuity, and visionary intergenerational strength. Sources I will continue to hold close include the power of ancestral connection, adaptation through adversity, and ongoing commitment to the Anishinaabe language."
Johnson said she appreciated the breadth and depth of the conversations. “I learned that even though most sources are incomplete, it’s important to get as close as you can to the original source material and individuals.
"Archives can be supplemented by letters, site visits, and oral interviews,” Johnson said. “I also learned that the process of going to the source can create community at the same time that it can reveal one.”
“I’m pleased that folks from Vassar and those from the Poughkeepsie community took the time
to be here today,” Maragh Taylor shared. “I think it’s vital that we pause sometimes to reflect
on who we are and what we’re doing. Slowing down to be in conversation, especially when
things are as hectic as they have been, can give us the stillness we need to check ourselves and
each other. And isn’t this a time when we need to do just that? I’m hoping we all dig deep to
figure out or remind ourselves of what grounds and guides us no matter what is going on
around us. For me, that’s what character is about, and I’m hoping we continue that
conversation on and off campus.”