Emmy-Winning Journalist Natasha Bertrand ’14 Returns to Vassar As Inaugural Guest of the Truth Project
A new series at The Vassar Institute for the Liberal Arts is delving into how truth forms the bedrock of a functioning democracy. As the inaugural Truth Project speaker, CNN national security correspondent Natasha Bertrand ’14, provided a fascinating look at what it takes to report the news accurately in a complex media landscape featuring high-stakes military gambits, vindictive political leaders, and disinformation that can spread rapidly with the help of AI.
The audience of students, faculty, and members of the public raptly listened to a conversation between Bertrand and one of her former Vassar mentors Shirley Ecker Boskey Professor of History and International Relations Robert K. Brigham, who also serves as the Institute’s Faculty Director. More than once, Bertrand noted that the liberal arts education she received at Vassar helped her develop the nimble mind essential to doing a job in which she must quickly master diverse and complicated topics—ranging from the Pentagon’s use of AI in targeting decisions to international law on war crimes to the history of the Kurdish population in Iran.
“I was a political science and philosophy major here at Vassar, and obviously that provided a fantastic foundation for all of my reporting to come,” said Bertrand, whose career trajectory also included staff positions at Business Insider, The Atlantic, and POLITICO. “The foundation that I got here, taking all these different classes in all these different areas, and being able to ask questions and think on your feet is really what helped me prepare for that. The craft kind of comes later as you work at it, but that foundation, I feel, is really core.”
Brigham asked Bertrand questions that got to the heart of what it takes to provide truthful news reports to the public. “Because you’re reporting on national security affairs, which is something that every administration wants to keep close to the vest and only leaks and declassifies when it suits their interest, you have to develop sources,” he noted. “So, how do you develop sources that you can trust while remaining objective about their agenda?”
Bertrand replied that the key was always keeping a source’s particular agenda in mind while also getting verification from as many other sources as possible. “When it comes to vetting sources in an administration like this, which is very abnormal in so many ways, just because they are constantly trying to entrap you with things that they can then turn around and say you have reported something inaccurately, you have to be extra, extra, extra, extra, super careful,” she said. “You can never have one person as a source.”
That’s why she and her newsroom colleagues always pool resources on any given story, she said. “We have really good sources who know things, but even they are often only getting a piece of the picture, no matter how high level they are—or if they’re getting the full picture, which is rare, they often only want to present one part of it because everyone has an agenda,” she explained. “And so, it’s just so important to pool resources and pool sources and pool expertise, and that’s why we can’t move as fast sometimes as we would like to, because we are under such a microscope right now, especially in this environment, that we just have to be really one thousand percent sure that what we’re writing is accurate and fair.”
Later in the program, Bertrand was asked what level of scrutiny was appropriate for members of the press.
“I think obviously there should always be scrutiny, and we’re human, and we’re going to get things wrong,” Bertrand acknowledged. What’s dangerous to the pursuit of truth, she said, is when small, inevitable mistakes are used as a reason to restrict access to information the public has the right to know. “I’ll give you an example,” she offered, noting that the administration had recently barred several media outlets, including CNN, from the White House—a subject of continuing litigation. “POLITICO did this recently, where they wrote a story, and upon further reporting, they realized that there was a little detail in it that was incorrect, and they went back and they corrected it. But that was weaponized to such an extent by the White House that it made the White House basically say, ‘See, this is why they should not be allowed to cover us. This is why they should not be allowed on the premises.’ And I just don’t think that’s fair.”
Bertrand also spoke about how she manages personal biases in the context of doing her job. “We all have biases, perspectives, and points of view, and that’s not something that we’re necessarily told we need to check at the door, because that’s just not possible, you’re human,” Bertrand replied. “And so I think the guiding light for us is something that [journalist] Christiana Amanpour always says, which is, ‘be truthful, not neutral.’ That is the ultimate foundation of everything, and that’s why we go through this rigorous process every time we put a story out to get all of the facts correct.”
“I was very proud of the launch of the Truth Project,” said Wesley Dixon, Institute Program Director and the creator of this series. “Natasha Bertrand was such a timely and appropriate guest to kick off this series. Natasha generously reflected on her experience navigating the dynamic journalistic and political environments as someone committed to objectivity, open inquiry, and truth. Natasha's conversation with Bob really allowed those in the audience to hear first-hand the different situations Natasha has had to navigate with respect to telling the truth about issues of national security.” Dixon also gratefully acknowledged the generous support of Truth Project donor Susan Perry Ferguson ’65, who attended the event. The next Truth Project speaker will be announced in the spring.